4. Wrightstown Meeting was not a bystander

It is tempting to treat the choice of a spot near the Wrightstown Meetinghouse as the walk’s starting point as a piece of pure stagecraft — a respectable Quaker setting borrowed by the Penn proprietors to lend the proceedings an air of fairness. The connection went further than that. Several of the men who made the walk legally and physically possible were drawn from the Wrightstown circle, and the Meeting itself sat at the operational center of what happened.

John Chapman, deputy surveyor

The most consequential Wrightstown figure on the walk was John Chapman, deputy surveyor of Bucks County. Chapman was the son of the John Chapman who arrived in 1684 as Wrightstown’s first English settler, and whose family had donated the four-acre parcel on which the first Wrightstown Friends Meetinghouse — a log building — went up in 1721. He was, in other words, both a working surveyor in the Penns’ employ and a member of the Wrightstown Meeting, near whose Meetinghouse the walk began.

Chapman rode with the walking party. After the walk he drew the 1737 map of the resulting tract — the working document by which the Penns’ surveyors translated Edward Marshall’s endpoint and the angled closing line back into salable parcels. He was, in practical terms, the local technical hand who turned an indefensible interpretation of an old draft deed into an enforceable piece of cartography. He died in 1743, six years after the walk.

Timothy Smith, sheriff and timekeeper

The walk’s official timekeeper was Timothy Smith, the sheriff of Bucks County. Smith’s job was to start the walkers at sunrise on September 19 and to stop them at noon on the second day, completing the agreed twelve hours of walking on the first day and six on the second. The Smith family appears repeatedly in the Wrightstown, Buckingham, and Middletown Friends records of the period, which places the sheriff within the same Bucks County Quaker world as Chapman.

James Yeates of Newtown

One of the three hired walkers, James Yeates, lived in Newtown, the township immediately south of Wrightstown. In 1737 Newtown had no Meeting of its own, and would not for another seventy-eight years; Friends living in Newtown attended worship at Wrightstown. So if Yeates was himself a Friend, his Meeting was Wrightstown — the same Meeting whose deputy-surveyor member John Chapman was riding next to him on horseback.

The Meetinghouse itself

The walk began at a marked chestnut tree near the Wrightstown Meetinghouse. The chestnut is gone, but the location remains the canonical starting point. Today the spot is marked by stones the Bucks County Historical Society placed in 1890 “to the memory of the Lenni Lenape Indians, ancient owners of this region,” and by the state’s 1947 marker beside them. Whether the tree stood within the four-acre parcel the Chapman family had donated in 1721 for the first log Meetinghouse, on adjacent Chapman land, or at a survey corner inherited from an earlier purchase, is not clearly established in the published secondary record — a detail the original Penn survey notes and the Wrightstown deed could settle, and that we would like to settle. What is clear is that on the morning of September 19, 1737, a Wrightstown Friend serving as deputy surveyor, a Bucks County sheriff, a hired walker from neighboring Newtown, and two Penn-appointed observers set out from this spot together to acquire 1.2 million acres for the Penn proprietors.

Did the Meeting ever take a stand?

The natural Quaker process for handling something like this would have been a minute of the Monthly Meeting expressing concern about the conduct of one of its members, or a query into whether the proceedings were consistent with Friends’ testimony of fair dealing with Indigenous peoples. No such minute from Wrightstown appears in the standard secondary accounts of the Walking Purchase. Pennsylvania Friends as a whole eventually came to treat the Walking Purchase as a major item in the long quarrel inside the Society of Friends about the colony’s treatment of the Lenape — but that reckoning came later, at the level of the Yearly Meeting and the colony, not at the level of the Meeting next to whose Meetinghouse the walk had begun.

The honest summary is that the Walking Purchase was not done over the Meeting’s objection. It was done by people the Meeting knew, in immediate sight of the Meetinghouse, under the eye of officials the Meeting tolerated; and the Meeting, so far as the surviving record shows, said nothing about it at the time.

← Previous: Origins of Wrightstown Friends Meeting

Next: What came after →