5. What came after: 1756 and 2004

The Walking Purchase has never had a clean ending. Two later moments stand out: a Quaker reckoning inside Pennsylvania politics in the 1750s, and a federal lawsuit in the 2000s.

The 1756 reckoning

The Walking Purchase did not stay buried as a private grievance for the Lenape. It surfaced again with force during the French and Indian War, when Lenape war parties raided the Pennsylvania frontier in the mid-1750s and explicitly cited the Walking Purchase as one of their reasons for taking up arms against the colony.

Pennsylvania, founded as a Quaker peaceable kingdom, suddenly needed a militia, fortifications, and military appropriations. The Quaker Party that had dominated the Pennsylvania Assembly for most of seven decades was now being asked to vote war funding against the very people the Penns had defrauded a generation earlier. In May 1756 six prominent Friends resigned their Assembly seats rather than vote for the war measures. The dominant Quaker political bloc in the Assembly was effectively finished as a governing force.

In the same year, a group of Philadelphia Friends led by Israel Pemberton Jr. organized the Friendly Association for Regaining and Preserving Peace with the Indians by Pacific Measures. The Friendly Association sent Quaker delegations to the treaty conferences at Easton in 1756 and 1757, where the Lenape leader Teedyuscung made the Walking Purchase grievance a matter of formal record. Teedyuscung was accompanied at Easton by Charles Thomson — later the perpetual secretary of the Continental Congress — acting as his scribe and advocate.

This is the moment at which the Walking Purchase moved, inside Pennsylvania Quakerism, from an awkward family matter into an acknowledged stain — one the Friendly Association then spent the better part of a decade trying to make right through diplomacy, gifts, and the patient cultivation of a peace that the proprietary government would not seek on its own.

The 2004 lawsuit

Two and a half centuries later the Lenape tried the question in court. In January 2004 the Delaware Nation, a federally recognized tribe now based in Anadarko, Oklahoma, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, naming the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Governor Edward Rendell, and the commissioners of Northampton and Bucks counties among the defendants.

The Delaware Nation sued as the successor in interest to “Moses” Tundy Tetamy, an eighteenth-century Lenape leader who had served as an interpreter at the Easton conferences and to whom the Penns had granted, by way of patent in 1741, a 315-acre tract in Northampton County called Tatamy’s Place. The suit sought a declaration that the Delaware Nation held aboriginal title and fee title to that specific 315 acres, on the ground that the Walking Purchase — which encompassed Tatamy’s Place — had been procured by fraud and could not have validly extinguished aboriginal title.

On November 30, 2004, the district court dismissed the complaint for failure to state a cause of action. The reasoning was the part the press underreported: the court did not say the Walking Purchase was not a fraud. The court accepted, for purposes of the motion to dismiss, that the Delaware Nation’s allegations of fraud were true. It held instead that fraud was legally irrelevant. Under longstanding federal Indian-law doctrine, aboriginal title is extinguished whenever a sovereign acts to extinguish it, and the sovereign’s motives, fairness, or honesty are not subject to judicial review. The Third Circuit affirmed in 2006 (Delaware Nation v. Pennsylvania, 446 F.3d 410), and the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

The 2004 dismissal therefore did not exonerate the Penns. It did the opposite, in a sense: a federal court formally recorded that, accepting the fraud as alleged, the law nevertheless provided no remedy.

What remains

The 1.2 million acres remain in the hands of the Penns’ successors and their later buyers. The Lenape endure: in the Delaware Tribe and the Delaware Nation in Oklahoma, in communities in Wisconsin and Ontario where their ancestors were pushed, and among Lenape people who remain in Pennsylvania and New Jersey today. Wrightstown Meeting still gathers on Sundays beside the spot where the walkers stepped off.

The chestnut tree is gone.

← Previous: Wrightstown Meeting was not a bystander

Next: Sources and further reading →